I have been in serious Spring cleaning/nesting mode over the last few weeks! I recently took the plunge and painted all of my trim and doors downstairs white. When we built the house in 2008, I went with a very creamy beige. I was ready to freshen and brighten everything up! I had the walls painted about a year ago. They are a very light grey called Dolphin Fin by Behr. I kept my trim the same color at that point to save money, but the yellow tone of the trim made my walls look blue. It’s crazy how colors can play tricks on your eyes! Now it’s all fixed! I went with Pure White by Sherwin-Williams for all of my doors and trim and I was happy! Well, almost happy! We have a huge stone fireplace in our living room. It really is the first thing you see when you walk in the door, and it’s the focal point of the inside of the house. It’s the same stone I have on the exterior, and I do love it, but crave change. I have considered lots of different options, from covering it with tile or even removing it altogether, but nothing fit my budget or felt right. Then, I ran across a picture of a fireplace on Pinterest. It appeared they had used some kind of white plaster to cover it. That’s all it took! The photo didn’t have details, but gave me the courage to give it a shot. I decided to do a German schmear on the stone. I have seen it done on brick a bazillion times and absolutely love it, but I questioned what it would look like on stone. Well… Here is how it turned out!

This is my fireplace before…

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation

And here she is now!

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation

Watch the video progress…

Many of you may have seen me tackle this project on Instagram stories a few weeks ago! If you missed those you can check them out by clicking the play button below. I threw them all in a video for you to make it easy!


The best part of this project is that I spent $63 in supplies to achieve it, and that includes the roll of paper on the ground! Here is what I used for this project…

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
ProLite Tile Mortar

The first thing you will need is WHITE tile mortar. These are sold at the hardware store in bags of powder and premixed tubs. I debated using the premixed over the powder, but chose to go with the powder because it saved money, and I was able to control the consistency of my mortar. It’s super easy to mix! You can see the mortar I used HERE.

I decided to brush my mortar on. I felt that I would be able to achieve the look I was going for more easily with a brush, and I knew it would be less messy than using a trowel or sponge to apply it. I found a great set of brushes on Amazon when I was painting my trim. They are perfect for this project! You can see them HERE!

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Great Paint Brush Set from Amazon

You will want to use a drill to mix the mortar. It’s the easiest way to get it mixed and even. I used a mixing attachment for this part and a $3 bucket from the paint section. My favorite mixing attachment can be found HERE on Amazon.

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Mortar Mixer Attachment

I used contractor’s paper to cover the floor around the fireplace. This stuff is inexpensive and I love to keep a roll in the garage for lots of different things! You can find it HERE!

You can also find it HERE at Home Depot.

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Builder’s Paper

Finally, you need a bucket to mix it in. I decided to mix small portions at a time. This stuff can get heavy and I knew I would be going up and down the ladder. I bought THIS BUCKET from HD. Super cheap and did the job!

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Mixing Bucket from Home Depot

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation Steps:

Now for the fun part! Let me show you how I did it!

I decided to take my mantel off just to avoid having to tape it off. If you can’t remove yours, I would just cover it with a plastic drop cloth and tope to keep it clean! After putting down paper and taping around the edge of the fireplace to protect my walls and paint, I mixed my first batch of mortar. I took a measuring cup from my kitchen (about a cup) and added 3 scoops of mortar to my bucket. I then added about 2 cups of water to that. You don’t need to measure this out exact AT ALL.

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Add Mortar mix to bucket
DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Pour water into mortar mix

Start by mixing this amount, and then check your consistency. You want to be able to brush it on, so I found that getting the consistency to the texture of peanut butter or a thicker icing was perfect for this application.

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Mortar consistency

You will notice that the WHITE mortar you purchase will look grey when mixed. This is totally normal, and the mixture will dry white. As my fireplace was drying, it kept getting more white.

I decided to start over on the side of the hearth. This is an area that nobody really sees, so I figured I could “practice” over there and get a good idea of what I was doing before moving to the other parts. I literally just brushed it right on.

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Brushing on mortar

Now, you may notice in the picture above that you see lots of brush strokes. I initially started with a brush I cut down to make more stiff. I was concerned that I would need a stiffer brush to apply this stuff. I found that this stiffness left the brush marks I really didn’t want, so I switched to a normal paintbrush at this point, which was one from the set I linked above.

Basically at this point, I worked my way around. This is where you can decide what you want yours to look like. You can add more mortar to get a more white look, or you can add less to keep more stone or brick exposed. Also, you can use a sponge to wipe away what you brush on. THESE are the sponges I used on mine. I only used mine to smooth brush strokes, bot really wipe away because I wanted #allthewhite.

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Sponges for wiping mortar

On this spot you can see the rougher edges of the mortar and some brush strokes.

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation

I used the wet sponge to smooth areas like this out. After letting the mortar sit for about 30-45 minutes, I used the sponge dampened with water to smooth those areas out.

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Smoothing rough areas and brush strokes with sponge

You can see below the progress I made. Again, I would let an area sit and set up for about 30-45 minutes before I smoothed it out.

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation

Once I finished the hearth, I worked my way up the wall!

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
Finished and drying!

Check out the finished fireplace!

So… How long did it take me?

I went to Home Depot that morning around 9 after I dropped the kids off at school. I made it home and began taping off around 10. I stopped to take care of the baby and do school pickup, and finished the job before 5pm that same day. Depending on the size of your fireplace, this is easily a 1 day job! And, the mortar dries fast. I did take a quick pick with decor that evening, but took it off to let the mortar dry overnight before dressing it up the next morning! For me, it was the best $63 I have spent in a long time!

I know there will be some of you that prefer the original stone and that’s ok! It’s just like painting and decorating… We all have our own tastes and opinions :-). You won’t change my mind on this one though… I LOVE IT! Let’s look at it some more, shall we??

DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation
DIY $65 Fireplace Transformation

Links to all the decor!

Wood wall arch

Small Vase

Large Vase


Fern Stems


Ashley and Whitney Blog post signature

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. How does the schmear hold up to every day use? Does it rub off on clothes or fall off the stone? Our kids sit on our fireplace in the winter. Wondering what that would do or cats jumping up on it and hanging out.

    1. I just completed this project maybe 2 weeks ago. I used pre mixed mortar though and watered it down so their results may have been different. Mine was crumbly at first around the edges of the stone and I worried any time we sit on it little pieces would come off and just be a mess. Initially this was true but once all these tiny bits fell off it has been fine and didn’t change the look, seriously they were tiny crumbs. Mine didn’t turn out as white as theirs, maybe it was my stone, maybe it was pre mixed mortar, maybe it is because I have crisp white cabinets next to it. Either way, it turned out so much better than the before. Good luck!

  2. Did it only require the 3 cups or did you end up running out and having to mix more? Husband didnt listen haha and just bought a container of the premixed stuff for this project. Debating on using it anyway as long as it should be enough or making him take it back.

  3. Thank you so much for this idea!!! It’s so beautiful! I ended up doing the exact same to mine!!! I get Bonus because My husband LOVES it!!!!! LOL

    1. I love this! I want to do mine but worry about it drying very white. My house has more creams and off white. Do you think I could add some color to the mix? Or do you think it will be ok with the stone showing through?

  4. I just love you gals and LOVE this fireplace!! I have another eyesore it’s a bright white fake brick fireplace like from 1990. I want a softer look, like yours. Help, any ideas

  5. It looks sooooo good! I much prefer the after. I do like some natural stone, but it depends on the color/type/age….some of the older stone looks outdated in the natural state, but when it’s painted like yours it looks amazing! Love it!!

    1. Do you find the wash stays on well? Has it chipped or rubbed off over time? We’re thinking doing our monster stone/red brick fireplace this same way. Just wondering about durability. Thanks!

  6. This looks fantastic! Is your stone pretty smooth? How do you think it would turn out on very textured stone?

  7. What a difference! I’ve never seen german schmear on stone, but it looks so good!! We just finished a faux german schmear on some faux brick paneling that we got and I’m obsessed too!

  8. Me, I’m a fan of brick, so this wouldn’t be something that I would do… but it DEFINITELY fits your look better! The old fireplace was a sore thumb in your home because it didn’t match. Now it does–looks great! Thanks for the great instructions as well. 🙂 <3

    1. Thank you Mariele!! I too love stone and brick, but I did feel so stuck with this one. I appreciate your sweet comment!

    1. You know Kim I’m not sure! I just loved the heavy messy look of this one… But I do love the look of lime wash on brick!

  9. I think it looks great! I’ve seen this done on brick before too & often wondered what it would look like on my stone fireplace. Hubby loves the stone, but I’ve always wanted something different. Thanks for the inspiration!

    1. Thank you Melanie! I was the exact same… I told myself it would look so odd on stone but I’m so glad I took the plunge 🙂